How to Choose a Psychotherapist in Toronto
- Karen MacKeigan
- Oct 1
- 4 min read
Updated: Oct 6
How to Find a Therapist: A Step-by-Step Guide
Starting therapy can be one of the most meaningful decisions you make for your mental health, but knowing where to begin often feels overwhelming. With so many options, different titles, approaches, and platforms, it’s normal to feel unsure. This guide is designed to help you take that first step with clarity and confidence. Whether you’re navigating stress, trauma, relationship struggles, or burnout, finding the right therapist in Toronto is possible and worth it.
1. Get Clear on Why You’re Seeking Therapy Start by identifying what’s bringing you to this search. Are you feeling overwhelmed at work? Are you struggling with unresolved trauma or relationship challenges? Do you want to explore patterns in your life that no longer serve you?
Therapists often specialize in areas like anxiety, depression, perfectionism, grief, trauma, or life transitions. Knowing your focus can help you narrow your options. And if you’re not sure what you need, that’s okay too. Sometimes, “I just know I need support” is more than enough to begin.
2. Learn the Titles: What’s the Difference Between an RP, RSW, and Psychologist?
In Ontario, several types of professionals provide therapy:
Registered Psychotherapists (RPs): Trained in talk therapy techniques and able to work with a wide range of emotional and psychological issues.
Registered Social Workers (RSWs): Often work from a systems perspective and may offer therapy focused on both emotional support and practical coping strategies.
Psychologists: Typically hold doctoral degrees and may offer both therapy and formal assessments (though not medication).
Psychiatrists: Medical doctors who can prescribe medication, though many focus on diagnosis and medication management rather than talk therapy.
There’s no universal “best;” it comes down to your needs and comfort level.
3. Choose Fit Over Perfection
A therapist’s credentials, training, and theoretical approach all matter, but nothing is more important than feeling safe and supported. Research consistently shows that the quality of the therapeutic relationship is the biggest factor in a successful outcome.
Many Toronto therapists offer free 15-minute consultations. Use this time to ask questions, share what you’re looking for, and notice how you feel. Do you feel heard? Do you sense empathy? There’s no pressure to commit after a single call, you’re allowed to explore.
4. Use Reputable Tools and Directories
When you're ready to start your search, the following platforms can help you find a therapist who fits your needs:
Psychology Today – Toronto: Search by issue, modality, gender, and more
TherapyOwl: A Canadian platform focused on quick bookings
First Session: Allows you to watch short intro videos from therapists
Ontario Association of Mental Health Professionals (OAMHP): A registry of licensed professionals in Ontario
You can also ask for referrals through trusted friends, your family doctor, or even your workplace's Employee Assistance Program (EAP), if available.
5. Ask the Right Questions
During your consultation or first session, consider asking:
What experience do you have with issues like mine?
What approach or modality do you use (CBT, DBT, EMDR, narrative therapy, etc.)?
What is your availability and session frequency?
What are your fees, and do you offer sliding scale pricing?
These questions can help set expectations and ensure you feel empowered in your choice.
6. Trust Your Gut, and Give Yourself Permission to Switch
Even with all the research and planning, sometimes the first therapist you try isn’t the right fit. That’s okay. Therapy is a personal experience, and it’s perfectly acceptable to switch if something doesn’t feel quite right. You’re not being “difficult," you’re advocating for your own well-being.
7. Consider Practicalities
Location, session format, and price all matter. Many Toronto therapists offer virtual appointments, which adds flexibility. Others have offices in neighbourhoods you may already visit. Most therapists in the Toronto area charge between $120 and $180 per session, with some offering lower-cost options or sliding scale rates. Check if your insurance covers Registered Psychotherapists or Social Workers, as this can help offset costs.
Final Thoughts: You’re Not Alone in This
Searching for a therapist is a brave and hopeful act. It means you’re prioritizing your mental health, even if you’re unsure of the exact path forward. Be kind to yourself as you navigate this process; clarity often comes through exploration.
If you’re ready to take the next step, you can learn more about our individual counselling services or get in touch to explore how we can support you.
About the Author
Karen MacKeigan, RP (Qualifying), RSSW, is a trauma-informed Registered Psychotherapist (Qualifying) and Registered Social Service Worker based in Toronto. With over five years of experience supporting adult survivors of childhood sexual abuse through her work at The Gatehouse, Karen brings an empathetic, client-centered approach to psychotherapy. She draws from a variety of therapeutic modalities to create a warm, safe, and collaborative space where clients feel heard and supported. Karen holds a BA in Psychology, an MA in Counselling Psychology, and diplomas in both Early Childhood Education and Addiction and Mental Health.
Comments